Is HbA1c Failing as a Diabetes Test in India?
Rising diabetes Burden
- diabetes cases are increasing rapidly across the world, especially in India.- HbA1c is widely used as the primary test for diagnosing and monitoring diabetes.- A new study published in The Lancet Regional health – Southeast Asia raises concerns about its reliability in indian populations.- Researchers warn that depending only on HbA1c may lead to missed or delayed diagnosis in many people.
What HbA1c Measures
- HbA1c reflects average blood sugar levels over the past 2–3 months.- It measures how much glucose is attached to hemoglobin in red blood cells.- Standard interpretation: - Below 5.7% — Normal - 5.7–6.4% — Prediabetes - 6.5% or above — Diabetes- It is commonly considered a “gold standard” test globally.
Why Accuracy Is Questioned
- HbA1c depends completely on hemoglobin quantity and quality.- If hemoglobin levels or red blood cell lifespan change, results can be distorted.- Conditions that affect results include: - iron deficiency anemia - hemoglobin genetic disorders - G6PD enzyme deficiency - Other blood-related diseases- These conditions are common in India, making HbA1c less reliable for many.
India-Specific Risk Factors
- Large segments of the indian population suffer from anemia and iron deficiency.- In some regions, over 50% of people are iron-deficient.- Rural and tribal populations are more severely affected.- Even urban hospital patients show red blood cell abnormalities.- In men with G6PD deficiency, diabetes diagnosis may be delayed by up to four years.
Expert Observations
- Study led by Prof. Anoop Mishra of Fortis C-Doc Centre of Excellence for Diabetes.- Researchers state HbA1c alone should not guide diagnosis in high-anemia populations.- Misleading results can cause both underdiagnosis and misdiagnosis.- Incorrect readings increase long-term complication risks.
Recommended Testing Approach
- Experts advise combining HbA1c with other diagnostic methods.- Suggested additional tests include: - Fasting blood glucose - Oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) - Regular blood sugar monitoring - Basic blood tests for anemia- In selected cases: - Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM) - Fructosamine testing- Personalized testing strategies are essential for accurate diabetes diagnosis in India.